Gold coins placed in jewelry: should I take them out of holders or leave in?

I'm organizing a family members' coin collection and found 3 gold coins inserted in holders to be used as jewelry charms. Two are on a bracelet and one is a necklace. Should I remove them or leave them as is for a professional to remove? I've stapled them into coin flips so I can catalog them—photos enclosed.

@Burton Strauss III @Randy Abercrombie @thomas mozzillo I would love your opinion here given your thoughtful responses to my other thread!

Thank you in advance for your help!

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Can you provide a closer shot of that Indian quarter-eagle so we can read the date, and shots showing the reverse of each coin so we can look for mint marks? (The gold dollar, the tiny one, has its date and any mint mark on the back.)

 

I would personally leave them as is. Right now, they're what I would consider an heirloom, because previous members wore this jewelry. How cool would it be to hold the pendant your great grandmother wore, for example. Anyway, the coins appear to be cleaned and will likely suffer from being mounted, so they're worth more to me as pendants than as scrap gold coins. Just my two cents. Would love to see better photos of each.

 

Lean towards @Seattlite86 comment if they have Family history. It does look like the coins could be unaltered - just in ring type holders.

 

I will try to post better pics over weekend but what I’m hearing is they are likely not going to grade well since they are in the holders and probably have been cleaned? Is that right?

The holders look like they are held by tension (not altered) if that’s what you meant @Tlberg ?

 

Yes @kookiez - that they had not been drilled or soldered

 

Of all the jewelry mounts, a bezel is the best - as in does the LEAST damage (soldering a loop or drilling a hole is worse). But the bezel will damage the rim and a TPG will grade them as "Ex Jewelry, AU Details" or similar.

Unless they are a super rare date, they will resale essentially at just the gold value ("melt").

Given the damage is done, if there is anybody in the family who would enjoy them as jewelry and for the family connection, keep them as they are, love them and pass them down. It's a connection to the great-great-great grandfather they never knew.

 

Please leave them the way they are as removing them adds no value. Just being mounted in a jewelry type holder has damaged the coin. One of your relatives may have worn these at some point so it should mean more to you as jewelry than the coin.

They are damaged, you can't see that until they are removed from the holders. They will not grade and that would be a waste of money. The holders themselves may add to their value.

Leaving them be is the only option in my opinion. Welcome to CT.

 

All good info. And coins can easily be removed from a bezel simply by turning the tiny bezel set screw near the pendent where the chain loops through. Yes, these will always be damaged coins that won’t grade. But, keep in mind too that the bezels themselves are likely gold... I recently purchased a gold bezel to mount a half eagle for my mom. The bezel cost me as much as the value of the coin! I would wager those bezels are gold.... As others have said, these may hold more family heirloom value remaining as they are. Because from a numismatic standpoint they will always be damaged.

 

The jewelry coins have been heavily cleaned. Unless there is
a super rare date they are bullion. If you remove them they will
be damaged worse than they already are.