1877-S Trade Dollar, interesting variety

I've been looking for the "broken arrows" variety for a couple of years now, both on eBay and Collectors corner; I had only run across one raw that had been harshly cleaned, so I skipped it. It is not in the CPG, but us TD nerds find it fascinating. Apparently, a master die was damaged, leading to "breakage" of two of the three arrowshafts on the reverse. Later, the mint attempted to repair this by re-hubbing the master, which created another variety, a DDR used on the 1878-S (that one IS in the CPG).
So here it is, with a closeup using the balky digital microscope.
Oh ,if you'd like to GTG, please feel free; I'll post that tomorrow evening.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Very cool
I like the look of your coin.
Very interesting variety.
I just bought a 1877 Mini S today variety C-53.1 today
reverse die break.
Mine Looks about AU-50

 

please post some pics when you get a chance.

 

Natural window light and under a jeweler light. I am not the best at photos. The finger prints are a little distracting but coin is super nice in hand. Great luster.
I may see if they can conserve it at NGC when I send it in.

 

Nice photos! Sure looks AU, good luck with the submission.

 

Please pardon my ignorance. What reference book are you using to attribute the coin as C-53.1? Thanks

 

I am not sure where it comes from but that is what it is listed under in the SSDC of vamworld and the trade challenge page there.

hopefully it is ok to link the trade challenge here
http://registry.ssdcvams.com/Trade/TradeChallenge50.pdf

 

Congrats on the find!
I'll guess XF 45

 

Just spent some time looking through the TradeChallenge50 download, whew! that is an exhaustive survey of the TD varieties. The author notes that the lower arrow on the broken arrows variety was later re engraved, and is much tougher to find. I think I have seen one of those on ebay in the past.

 

Neat Variety.
The reverse looks closer to XF40.
I will say XF45.

 

Nice example and an informative post.

 

Other than minor obverse rim dings and reverse rim gouge it looks great. Toning is good. I like it, Easy XF perhaps low AU. Thanks for sharing your winner.

 

Here is 1, 1877-P, I traded for on 7-18-2021 at the Royal Oak (MI) Coin Show, which was the first show I went to after the pandemic. The holder says AU 55. It is now in my safe deposit box

 

Nice looking 77-P Jim; allowing for some wear yours is better struck than most, often Liberty's head and the upper 3 stars on the right are very flat. Well preserved surfaces too.

 

Here is a 77-P (PCGS AU50) with about as good a strike as you are likely to see on this particular issue:

 

Hmm, been a while since I've looked at the enlarged photos, may have to get those green spots checked out!

 

Thank you for your comments. I had always wanted a trade $, and it was my first coin show since 1971.

 

I think I went to a coin show around 1969 with my dad, then didn't go to another one until 2014!

 

well, as to the grade of the broken arrows, ngc gave it xf45, pretty sharp group here!

 

That IS a nice looking Broken Arrows. I have seen a few on Ebay over the years. In fact, that's where I got mine, which graded XF40. I think this variety looks best in XF grades - the extra wear wipes out a little more of the arrow remnants making them almost invisible. BTW - I was the underbidder on your coin - you would have gotten it for a little less if not for me!!!
Here's mine: